Glee news, episodes, music, and more!
Glee may have become a phonomenon in Europe and America alike, but like many a Series, it has started to receive its first bout of negative publicity.
An article published in The Irish Times on the 12th of february (Glee: The anti-Christian arguement) focuses in on the criticism Glee is receiving for its scandalous storylines.
The United States Parents Television Council claim that the show is unsafe for teenage viewing, containing sexually charged storylines. One particular episode, Showmance, really got their goat, and it seems that they are looking for any possible way to downgrade the popular teenage series.
Time Magazine’s Nancy Gibbs told readers of how a certain Christian Minister is labelling Glee as ‘Anti-Christian’. This minister believes that Glee ‘portrays Christians as phonies and hypocrites’.
“The students lie, they cheat, they steal, they lust…Nearly all the Ten Commandments get violated at one point or another, while the audience is invited to laugh at people’s pain and folly and humiliation”
Don’t you think that is going a little too far?
The said Christian Minister must not have stopped to think about the many shows that are now available for teens to watch, like The Hills and Gossip Girl. Look at Gossip Girl for instance. Gossip Girl is a show enjoyed by millions of teens all over the globe, and contains drugs, sex, lies and lust. Jenny Humphrey, perfect teen beauty queen/drug dealer. Serena Van Der Woodsen, member of Manhattan’s elite/mistress.
Then we look at Glee. Yes, maybe the fact that Mr.Schuester is straying from his wife, and yes, maybe the head of the Celibacy Club is pregnant, like I saw when I watch Secret Life of the American Teenager, but we don’t see the level of maturity that we see in Gossip Girl. Glee’s heavy storylines are lightened by its catchy songs and happy-go-lucky mood throughout. Its sensitive teenage issues are dealt with in a way that would make the most apprehensive teenager learn to deal. (For example, Kurt coming out to his parents)
A show that can be enjoyed by the whole family has finally been brought to our television screens and people are still unhappy. In my opinion, there are much worse things on TV right now that are potentially ‘anti-christian’ and it’s very rare that we hear people complaining!
Whats your opinion, is Glee potentially Anti-Christian?
Nicola xx
No related posts.
You've found the perfect place to catch up on Glee news, songs, and episode info. Take part in discussions about the latest that's going on in the world of Glee. Welcome to the Glee Club!
They make a point – at first I was like no way! But if you look at Gossip Girl and the like, you KNOW what the characters are like and to expect that from the show, whereas you would assume that Glee is safe to watch.
Fair enough in GG everyone seems to have slept with everyone but in Glee, it’s the “christians” or the married people who seem to be going that way so….yeah…….
Glee is so not anti-Christian. The Christian Minister’s just mad cuz all the kids nowadays are having such a great time watching glee!
Glee is in no way anti-Christian. I’d say the script-writers had Quinn be head of the celibacy club because that would make her pregnancy more dramatic and harder to deal with. It also fits into her character’s stereotype.
As for Mr. Schuester leaving his wife, there’s divorce in almost every show nowadays! Look at Bree in Desperate Housewives!
The Christian Minister needs to realize that the show is for entertainment purposes, not sending out subliminal anti-Christian messages.
I wouldn’t consider the show anti christian. I think it just go’s to show how many people in Ministerial positions in this country are out of touch with what our children deal with and the complexities of their everyday lives in these times. Teenage pregnancy and Divorce aswell as casual relationship and drugs, are issues our children see and or deal with on a daily basis among their own families and friends or see happening in their school and community.I personally think that it is important that shows like Glee continue to tackle and dare I say embrace these issues. Several episodes have opened the door for discussion in my home, a rare and welcome occurance. If what is happening in a T.V. show gives me the chance to openly discuss topics which even in todays modern Ireland can be quite taboo, I welcome every episode, every character and every story line!!!
waaat!!they complained about divorces!! half the homes in America are divorced!!and how can you complain about it being “anti christian”so what theres a few Jews in it! and its exactly what real lifes about and we all have to deal with that at one point or another.Typical christian minister always have to complain about something that doesnt have a last supper in it
Agreed! Thankyou all for your comments.
i pet a worm 2day
Hi nat you are right you make a great point xx
i bought a spoon 2day!
You guys are right. The minstir really needs to get a grip. This is what some kids go through everyday.
I think Glee is really cool and fun and I love the gay guy he’s hilly. And Mercadies is like nearly as good as Beyonce and Whitney Housten.
Love you all
Bex xxooxx
Hey guys,
I completley agree with you all. I think the Miniser needs too get a life. There is absoutley nothing wrong with glee at all. The singing and dancing is amazing and that is mostly why people watch it. The singers on Glee are amazing esp. Mercadies she is well up there with Beyonce and Whitney. And i didnt copy Bex i gave her that idea shes my cuz im staying in her house 2nite.
Nicola you are defo right.
Love all you guys loads
Ros xoox!
Yeah, you guys are totally right, thankyou for your comments! Looking forward to season 2?
Nicola x
Hey Nicola is Glee defo on 2nite? xoox